Every morning I take about 30 minutes to sort through the hundreds of emails I get from our various sites. Supergirl obviously is the bulk of that email. I was struck by one such email this morning and I want to share it with you. I won't say who it's from but I want you all to see it:
I used to post here but haven’t in long time. I have continued to visit because of what a great looking site you have, full of beautiful pictures and really useful info. I’ve also continued to peruse the comments section. Not anymore. What used to be a varied and fairly in depth discussion of the show has turned into a constant howl about how they’ve ruined it. The negative roar begins based on just an episode description, a few sentences. If you already “know” it’s no good why watch? I read here that 1 or 2 parts of the overall series story that I am enjoying are just “clutter”. What’s ruined is my enjoyment.
I still recommend Supergirl.tv but tell people to avoid the comments.
Supergirl.tv is essentially Kelsey and I's love letter to our favorite comic book character. The site is meant to be a service to fans to gather and share their comments on the show. I too have noticed the increasing negativity regarding the show. Our forum is now filled with posts about removing the show runners or writing a better season 4.
I pause here because I don't know what to do at this point. We don't make money on the site. I don't need the traffic for revenue or anything. It honestly costs us money to run our little comicbook show empire. But we do this because we love it. So that said, I could say only say nice things and watch our userbase decline but I don't want to police bad comments, that isn't the point. Free speech and all that. I don't think the site would fulfill its nature if we couldn't criticize the show.
But I do want this to be a fun place. I like to think that at one time, when the show's fanbase was so deeply divided on Mon-El and Maggie that this was the one place for rational discussion. I get that this season has been a rough one for many viewers. I know the politics have been turned up a lot this year.
I think I am losing my message here. I don't know what to do to make this place fun again. Maybe I can't because the site reflects the fans feelings on the show. Maybe when the show is good the site is good, I don't know.
I am not going to change any policies on the site. I am not going to change any rules or conditions. It should be business as usual. Maybe just saying this will inspire. If you have any ideas how I could do better as admin or what I could do to make the site culture better please let me know. I want this place to continue to be THE supergirl resource its always been.
Thanks,
Eric & Kelsey